Attention
1) Debate date change : Debate date change can be request if both team agreed and proposed date can be arranged by Working Committee.
2) Debate Motion and standpoint :
Motion will be announced one week in advance on Debate webpage.
Standpoint is decided by the last digit of the closing figure of Hang Seng Index 1 day before the debate.
Odd – Team A (Affirmative) and Team B (Opposition)
Even – Team A (Opposition) and Team B (Affirmative)
Inter-city (BJ-HK and SH-HK) Motion and Standpoint
Motion
Invite Mainland China schools to propose a list of motion, submit to Hong Kong Working Committee for comment. Draw to decide the motion.
Motions will be announced on web 10 days before the debate.
Standpoint
There is an option for each team to pick their own standpoint.
If there is a conflict, standpoint is decided by Hang Seng index (as metioned above).
The details of the "Putonghua Pilot Class" (Chinese only)
Attention :
Due to change request, debate sequence may be changed; A mark
will indicate the next match.
A. Primary schools Cantonese section (1st round)
|
Match |
Date |
Time |
Team A |
Team B |
Motion (Double click the motion for review) |
|
1st match (HSI：27210) |
2007.12.04(Tue) | 4:30pm~5:30pm |
S.K.H. Yan Laap Primary School (Opposition Side) Winner Motion Carried |
Sharon Lutheran School (Affirmative Side) |
懲罰能有效改善學生紀律問題 (Debate Replay) (Link to YouTube) |
|
2nd match (HSI：27371) |
2007.12.05(Wed) | 4:30pm~5:30pm |
T.W.G.Hs. Tam Shiu Primary School (Affirmative Side) Winner Motion Defeated |
Kowloon City Baptist Church Hay Nien Primary School (Opposition Side) |
本地大學優先錄取資優兒童利多於弊 (Debate Replay) (Link to YouTube) |
|
3rd match (HSI：29226) |
2007.12.18(Tue) | 4:30pm~5:30pm |
Po Leung Kuk Grandmont Primary School (Opposition Side) |
Po Leung Kuk Tin Ka Ping Primary School (Affirmative Side) Winner Motion Defeated |
當政府增加教育開支，專上教育應優先於基礎教育 (Debate Replay) (YouTube 版) |
|
4th match |
2007.12.08(Sat) | 10:30am~11:30am |
St.Bonaventure Catholic Primary School (Affirmative Side) |
P.L.K. Stanley Ho Sau Nan Primary School (Opposition Side) Winner Motion Carried |
全港小學應以普通話教授中國語文科 (Debate Replay) (Link to YouTube) |
|
5th match (HSI：28643) |
2007.12.08(Sat) | 1:30pm~2:30pm |
Kwong Ming Ying Loi School (Affirmative Side) |
Lok Sin Tong Primary School (Opposition Side) Winner Motion Carried |
學校應禁售零食 (Debate Replay) (Link to YouTube) |
|
6th match (HSI：28643) |
2007.12.08(Sat) | 3:00pm~4:00pm |
Ho Shun Primary School (Sponsored by Sik Sik Yuen) (Affirmative Side) Winner Motion Defeated |
W F Joseph Lee Primary School (Opposition Side) |
小學教科書採用漫畫能令學生更易理解課文內容 (Debate Replay) (Link to YouTube) |
|
7th match |
2007.12.14(Fri) | 4:45pm~5:45pm |
Q.E.S. Old Students' Association Branch Primary School (Opposition Side) Winner Motion Carried |
Sacred Heart Of Mary Catholic Primary School (P.M.) (Affirmative Side) |
小班教學有效提升教學質素 (Debate Replay) (YouTube 版) |
|
8th match |
2007.12.12(Wed) | 4:30pm~5:30pm |
Buddhist Wing Yan School (A.M.) (Affirmative Side) Winner Motion Defeated |
Ping Shek Estate Catholic Primary School (Opposition Side) |
中學應容許學生外出午膳 (Debate Replay) (Link to YouTube) |
A. Primary schools Cantonese section (Quarter-finals)
|
Match |
Date |
Time |
Team A |
Team B |
Motion (Double click the motion for review) |
|
9th match (HSI：25837) |
2008.01.22(Tue) | 4:30pm~5:30pm |
S.K.H. Yan Laap Primary School (Affirmative Side) |
T.W.G.Hs. Tam Shiu Primary School (Opposition Side) Winner Motion Carried |
香港政府應實行兒童發展基金 (Debate Replay) |
|
10th match (HSI：24450) |
2008.01.23(Wed) | 4:30pm~5:30pm | Po Leung Kuk Tin Ka Ping Primary School (Opposition Side) Winner Motion Carried |
P.L.K. Stanley Ho Sau Nan Primary School (Affirmative Side) |
兒童揀飲擇食家長應負最大責任 (Debate Replay) |
|
11th match (HSI：25114) |
2008.01.24(Thu) | 4:30pm~5:30pm | Lok Sin Tong Primary School (Opposition Side) Winner Motion Carried |
Ho Shun Primary School (Sponsored by Sik Sik Yuen) (Affirmative Side) |
「潮流用語」損害學生語文能力 (Debate Replay) |
|
12th match |
2008.01.25(Fri) | 4:30pm~5:30pm | Q.E.S. Old Students' Association Branch Primary School (Affirmative Side) |
Buddhist Wing Yan School (A.M.) (Opposition Side) Winner Motion Carried |
小學課程應加入中國歷史科 (Debate Replay) |
A. Primary schools Cantonese section (Semi-finals)
|
Match |
Date |
Time |
Team A |
Team B |
Motion (Double click the motion for review) |
| 13th match (HSI：24148) |
2008.02.22(Fri) | 4:30pm~5:30pm | T.W.G.Hs. Tam Shiu Primary School (Opposition Side) Winner Motion Carried |
Po Leung Kuk Tin Ka Ping Primary School (Affirmative Side) |
英超聯應安排賽事於外地進行 (Debate Replay) |
| 14th match (HSI：24148) |
2008.02.23(Sat) | 2:30pm~4:00pm | Lok Sin Tong Primary School (Opposition Side) Winner Motion Carried |
Buddhist Wing Yan School (A.M.) (Affirmative Side) |
市民應罷買娛樂雜誌 (Debate Replay) |
A. Primary schools Cantonese section (Final)
|
Match |
Date |
Time |
Team A |
Team B |
Motion (Double click the motion for review) |
|
|
2008.07.01(Tue) | 9:30am~10:30am | T.W.G.Hs. Tam Shiu Primary School (Opposition Side) Winner Motion Carried |
Lok Sin Tong Primary School (Affirmative Side) |
維基百科對培養學習能力弊多于利 |
B. Secondary schools Cantonese section (1st round)
|
Match |
Date |
Time |
Team A |
Team B |
Motion (Double click the motion for review) |
|
1st match (HSI：28128) |
2007.12.31(Mon) | 4:30pm~6pm |
ST JOSEPH'S COLLEGE (Opposition Side) Winner Motion Carried |
MUNSANG COLLEGE (HONG KONG ISLAND) (Affirmative Side) |
政府不應資助立法會地區直選候選人 (Debate Replay) (Link to YouTube) |
|
2nd match (HSI：28521) |
2007.12.19(Wed) | 4:30pm~6pm |
KING LING COLLEGE (Affirmative Side) Winner Motion Defeated |
ST JOSEPH'S ANGLO-CHINESE SCHOOL (Opposition Side) |
本港政府應立法制定最低工資 (Debate Replay) (Link to YouTube) |
|
3rd match (HSI：27744) |
2007.12.20(Thu) | 4:30pm~6pm |
ST. MARK'S SCHOOL (Opposition Side) Winner Motion Carried |
ST CATHARINE'S SCHOOL FOR GIRLS (KWUN TONG) (Affirmative Side) |
香港應再次申辦亞運 (Debate Replay) (Link to YouTube) |
|
4th match |
2008.01.26(Sat) | 10:30am~12:00pm |
KIANGSU - CHEKIANG COLLEGE (KWAI CHUNG) (Affirmative Side) Winner Motion Defeated |
ELEGANTIA COLLEGE (SPONSORED BY EDUCATION CONVERGENCE) (Opposition Side) |
政府應收購西區海底隧道 (Debate Replay) |
|
5th match (HSI：27370) |
2008.01.04(Fri) | 4:30pm~6pm |
QUALIED COLLEGE (Opposition Side) |
DIOCESAN GIRLS' SCHOOL (Affirmative Side) Winner Motion Defeated |
港府不應增加注資香港迪士尼樂園 (Debate Replay) (Link to YouTube) |
|
6th match (HSI：27370) |
2008.01.05(Sat) | 10: 30am~12: pm |
HK & KLN KAIFONG WOMEN'S ASSOCIATION SUN FONG CHUNG COLLEGE (Opposition Side) Winner Motion Carried |
PO KOK SECONDARY SCHOOL (Affirmative Side) |
區議會應全面取消委任議席 (Debate Replay) (Link to YouTube) |
|
7th match |
2008.01.19(Sat) |
10:30am~12:00pm |
QUEEN'S COLLEGE (Affirmative Side) Winner Motion Defeated |
ST BONAVENTURE COLLEGE & HIGH SCHOOL (Opposition Side) |
人民幣匯率應於此時升值 (Debate Replay) |
|
8th match |
2008.01.19(Sat) |
5:00pm~6:30pm |
IMMACULATE HEART OF MARY COLLEGE (Affirmative Side) |
WA YING COLLEGE (Opposition Side) Winner Motion Carried |
港府實施長者醫療券利多於弊 (Debate Replay) |
B. Secondary schools Cantonese section (Quarter-finals)
|
Match |
Date |
Time |
Team A |
Team B |
Motion (Double click the motion for review) |
|
9th match (HSI：23818) |
2008.01.28(Mon) | 4:30pm~6pm | ST JOSEPH'S COLLEGE (Opposition Side) Winner Motion Carried |
KING LING COLLEGE (Affirmative Side) |
政府應准許民間電台廣播 (Debate Replay) |
|
10th match (HSI：21757) |
2008.01.29(Tue) | 4:30pm~6pm | ST. MARK'S SCHOOL (Affirmative Side) Winner Motion Defeated |
KIANGSU - CHEKIANG COLLEGE (KWAI CHUNG) (Opposition Side) |
美國經濟經已陷入衰退 (Debate Replay) |
|
11th match (HSI：24090) |
2008.01.30(Wed) | 4:30pm~6pm | DIOCESAN GIRLS' SCHOOL (Opposition Side) Winner Motion Carried |
HK & KLN KAIFONG WOMEN'S ASSOCIATION SUN FONG CHUNG COLLEGE (Affirmative Side) |
港府無力改善香港空氣質素 (Debate Replay) |
|
12th match |
2008.01.31(Thu) | 4:30pm~6pm | QUEEN'S COLLEGE (Affirmative Side) |
WA YING COLLEGE (Opposition Side) Winner Motion Carried |
京都議定書有效改善全球暖化 (Debate Replay) |
B. Secondary schools Cantonese section (Semi-finals)
|
Match |
Date |
Time |
Team A |
Team B |
Motion (Double click the motion for review) |
| 13th match (HSI：22921) |
2008.02.19(Tue) | 4:30pm~6pm | ST JOSEPH'S COLLEGE (Affirmative Side) |
ST. MARK'S SCHOOL (Opposition Side) Winner Motion Carried |
港府應立法推行全面停車熄匙 (Debate Replay) |
| 14th match (HSI：23169) |
2008.02.20(Wed) | 4:30pm~6pm |
DIOCESAN GIRLS' SCHOOL (Affirmative Side) Winner Motion Carried |
WA YING COLLEGE (Opposition Side) |
港府今年應多發一個月綜援 (Debate Replay) |
B. Secondary schools Cantonese section (Final)
|
Match |
Date |
Time |
Team A |
Team B |
Motion (Double click the motion for review) |
|
15th match |
2008.07.01(Sat) | 10:30 a.m~12:00 pm | ST. MARK'S SCHOOL (Affirmative Side) |
DIOCESAN GIRLS' SCHOOL (Opposition Side) Winner Motion Carried |
語文教學政策微調有效提升語文水平 |
C. Inter-city Primary schools Cantonese section
|
Match |
Date |
Time |
Team A |
Team B |
Motion (Double click the motion for review) |
| 1st match (HSI：23735) |
2008.02.25(Mon) | 4:30pm~5:30pm |
The Mission Covenant Church Holm Glad Primary School (Affirmative Side) Total 793 Winner Motion Carried |
南海官窯中心小學 (Opposition Side) Total 758 |
漫畫對少年成長弊多於利 (Debate Replay) |
| 2nd match (HSI：24123) |
2008.02.26(Tue) | 4:30pm~5:30pm |
Christian Alliance S.Y. Yeh Memorial Primary School (Affirmative Side) Total 815 Winner Motion Carried |
南海區師附小學 (Opposition Side) Total 772 |
學校不應要求小學生背誦中國經典文學詩詞 (Debate Replay) |
|
3rd match (HSI：23590) |
2008.02.27(Wed) | 4:30pm~5:30pm |
Stewards Pooi Kei Primary School (Opposition Side) Total 785 Winner Motion Carried |
南海區實驗小學 (Affirmative Side) Total 775 |
學校服務生必須是品學兼優的學生 (Debate Replay) |
|
4th match |
2008.04.06(Sun) | 5:00pm~6:00pm |
Chan Sui Ki (La Salle) Primary School (Affirmative Side) Total:835 Winner Motion Carried |
南海區師附小學 (Opposition Side) Total:820 |
考試是選拔人才的最佳方法 (Debate Replay) |
|
5th match (HSI：23305) |
2008.02.29(Fri) | 4:30pm~5:30pm |
Shap Pat Heung Rural Committee Kung Yik She Primary School (Affirmative Side) Total 708 |
南海區實驗小學 (Opposition Side) Total 740 Winner Motion Carried |
學校教育比家庭教育更為重要 (Debate Replay) |
|
6th match (HSI：23305) |
2008.03.01(Sat) | 10:30am~11:30am |
Lok Sin Tong Primary School (Affirmative Side) Total 914 |
南海區實驗小學 (Opposition Side) Total 924 Winner Motion Carried |
治亂世應用重典 (Debate Replay) |
|
7th match |
2008.05.05(Mon) | 6:00pm~7:30pm |
T.W.G.Hs. Tam Shiu Primary School (Opposition Side) Total:805 |
南海區南海實驗小學 (Affirmative Side) Total:838 Winner Motion Carried |
小學生擁有手機利多于弊 (Debate Replay) |
|
8th match (HSI：23305) |
2008.03.01(Sat) | 3:00pm~4:00pm |
Q.E.S. Old Students' Association Branch Primary School (Affirmative Side) Total 891 Winner Motion Carried |
南海區海三路小學 (Opposition Side) Total 868 |
人性本善而非性本惡 (Debate Replay) |
| 9th match (HSI：23305) |
2008.03.02(Sun) | 10:30am~11:30am |
Ho Shun Primary School (Sponsored by Sik Sik Yuen) (Affirmative Side) Total 875 |
南海南師附小 (Opposition Side) Total 911 Winner Motion Carried |
青少年應有崇拜的偶像 (Debate Replay) |
|
10th match (HSI：23305) |
2008.03.02(Sun) | 1:30pm~2:30pm |
P.L.K. Stanley Ho Sau Nan Primary School (Affirmative Side) Total 1007 Winner Motion Carried |
南海區官窯中心小學 (Opposition Side) Total 880 |
強權能勝公理 (Debate Replay) |
|
11th match |
2008.03.02(Sun) | 3:00pm~4:00pm |
C.C.C. But San Primary School (Affirmative Side) Total 738 Winner Motion Carried |
桂園小學 (Opposition Side) Total 710 |
互聯網對學生利大於弊 (Debate Replay) |
|
12th match (HSI：23269) |
2008.03.03(Mon) | 4:30pm~5:30pm |
Kowloon City Baptist Church Hay Nien Primary School (Affirmative Side) Total:691 |
南海區師附小學 (Opposition Side) Total: 717 Winner Motion Carried |
強將手下無弱兵 (Debate Replay) |
|
13th match (HSI：23714) |
2008.03.04(Tue) | 4:30pm~5:30pm |
Kwong Ming Ying Loi School (Opposition Side) Total: 822 Winner Motion Carried |
南海區海三路小學 (Affirmative Side) Total: 793 |
人為別人活著更快樂
(Debate Replay) |
|
14th match |
2008.03.05(Wed) | 4:30pm~5:30pm |
S.K.H. Yan Laap Primary School (Affirmative Side) Total:771 Winner Motion Carried |
南海南師附小 (Opposition Side) Total:704 |
學校應視學生如顧客 (Debate Replay) |
|
15th match (HSI：24591) |
2008.03.07(Fri) | 4:30pm~5:30pm |
Ping Shek Estate Catholic Primary School (Opposition Side) Total:923 Winner Motion Carried |
南海實驗小學 (Opposition Side) Total:827 |
人禍比天災更可怕 (Debate Replay) |
C. Inter-city Primary schools Cantonese section (Semi-finals) (2 teams from Hong Kong and 2 teams from China in the semi-finals)
|
Match |
Date |
Time |
Team A |
Team B |
Motion (Double click the motion for review) |
|
16th match (HSI：25449) |
2008.05.15(Thu) | 4:30pm~5:30pm | P.L.K. Stanley Ho Sau Nan Primary School (Affirmative Side) Total:853 |
南海實驗小學 (Opposition Side) Total:939 Winner Motion Carried |
《愚公移山》故事中愚公一家應搬家而非移山 (Debate Replay) |
|
17th match (HSI：25063) |
2008.05.22(Thu) | 6:00pm~7:30pm | Ping Shek Estate Catholic Primary School (Affirmative Side) Total:1000 Winner Motion Carried |
南海南師附小 (Opposition Side) Total:939 |
代溝主要責任在父母而非子女 (Debate Replay) |
C. Inter-city Primary schools Cantonese section (Final) (1 team from Hong Kong and 1 team from China in the Final)
|
Match |
Date |
Time |
Team A |
Team B |
Motion (Double click the motion for review) |
|
18th match (HSI：25043) |
2008.05.29(Thu) | 5:00pm~6:00pm | Ping Shek Estate Catholic Primary School (Affirmative Side) |
南海實驗小學 (Opposition Side) Winner Motion Carried |
環保產品不環保 (Debate Replay) |
D. Inter-city Secondary schools Cantonese section
|
Match |
Date |
Time |
Team A |
Team B |
Motion (Double click the motion for review) |
|
1st match (HSI：24331) |
2008.03.08(Sat) | 10:30am~12:00pm |
HO FUNG COLLEGE (SPONSORED BY SIK SIK YUEN) (Affirmative Side) Total:793 |
南海區南海實驗中學 (Opposition Side) Total:908 Winner Motion Carried |
港幣應與人民幣掛勾 (Debate Replay) |
|
2nd match (HSI：24331) |
2008.03.08(Sat) | 1:30pm~3:00pm |
LA SALLE COLLEGE (Affirmative Side) Total:842 Winner Motion Carried |
南海區桃園中學 (Opposition Side) Total:833 |
良好的國民教育是國家富強的最重要基石 (Debate Replay) |
|
3rd match (HSI：24331) |
2008.03.08(Sat) | 3:30am~5:00pm |
STEWARDS POOI TUN SECONDARY SCHOOL (Affirmative Side) Total:777 |
南海區鹽步中學 (Opposition Side) Total:813 Winner Motion Carried |
克隆人有利於人類發展
(Debate Replay) |
|
4th match |
2008.03.09(Sun) | 1:30pm~3:00pm |
WA YING COLLEGE (Affirmative Side) Total:880 Winner Motion Carried |
南海區實驗中學 (Opposition Side) Total:823 |
中學生結交網友利大於弊 (Debate Replay) |
|
5th match (HSI：24331) |
2008.03.09(Sun) | 3:30pm~5:00pm |
ST ROSE OF LIMA'S COLLEGE (Affirmative Side) Total:807 Winner Motion Carried |
南海區鹽步中學 (Opposition Side) |
法律是偏袒有錢人 (Debate Replay) |
|
6th match (HSI：23584) |
2008.03.10(Mon) | 4:30pm~6:00pm |
BUDDHIST WONG WAN TIN COLLEGE (Opposition Side) Total:745 Winner Motion Carried |
南海區平洲高中 (Affirmative Side) Total:720 |
通才比專才更切合當今社會需要 (Debate Replay) |
|
7th match |
2008.03.11(Tue) | 4:30pm~6:00pm |
MUNSANG COLLEGE (HONG KONG ISLAND) (Affirmative Side) Total:843 |
南海區小塘中學 (Opposition Side) Total:803 Winner Motion Carried |
中國的一孩政策予以保留利多於弊 |
|
8th match |
2008.03.12(Wed) | 4:30pm~6:00pm |
FUKIEN SECONDARY SCHOOL (Opposition Side) Total:779 Winner Motion Carried |
南海區石門實驗中學 (Affirmative Side) Total:795 |
社會道德比學術自由更為重要 (Debate Replay) |
|
9th match (HSI：23342) |
2008.03.13(Thu) | 4:30pm~6:00pm |
YMCA OF HONG KONG CHRISTIAN COLLEGE (Opposition Side) Total:920 Winner Motion Carried |
南海區黃岐中學 (Affirmative Side) Total:911 |
擇業應以興趣為先 (Debate Replay) |
|
10th match (HSI：22501) |
2008.03.15(Sat) | 4:00am~5:00pm |
ELCHK LUTHERAN SECONDARY SCHOOL (Affirmative Side) Total:902 Winner Motion Carried |
南海區桃園中學 (Opposition Side) Total:827 |
日常生活電子化利多於弊 (Debate Replay) |
|
11th match |
2008.04.13(Sun) | 5:00pm~6:00pm |
IMMACULATE HEART OF MARY COLLEGE (Affirmative Side) Total:795 Winner Motion Carried |
南海巿平洲高中 (Opposition Side) Total:782 |
治愚比治貧更為重要 (Debate Replay) |
|
12th match (HSI：22501) |
2008.03.16(Sun) | 10:30am~12:00pm |
KIANGSU - CHEKIANG COLLEGE (KWAI CHUNG) (Affirmative Side) Total:803 |
南海平洲高中 (Opposition Side) Total:944 Winner Motion Carried |
成大事者應不拘小節 (Debate Replay) |
|
13th match (HSI：22501) |
2008.03.16(Sun) | 1:30pm~3:00pm |
THE MISSION COVENANT CHURCH HOLM GLAD COLLEGE (Affirmative Side) Total:934 Winner Motion Carried |
南海中學 Total:844 (Opposition Side) |
政府不應控制私家車數量 (Debate Replay) |
|
14th match |
2008.03.19(Wed) | 5:30pm~6:30pm |
ST JOSEPH'S ANGLO-CHINESE SCHOOL (Opposition Side) Total:907 Winner Motion Carried |
南海區南海中學 (Affirmative Side) Total:864 |
中學生不應攜帶手提電話上學 (Debate Replay) |
|
15th match |
2008.03.17(Mon) | 4:30pm~6:00pm |
PUI CHING MIDDLE SCHOOL (Affirmative Side) |
南海區石門中學 (Opposition Side) |
學生應有權利參與制定校規 |
|
16th match (HSI：22995) |
2008.03.18(Tue) | 4:30pm~6:00pm |
ST FRANCIS' CANOSSIAN COLLEGE (Affirmative Side) Total:807 |
南海區石門中學獅山校區 (Opposition Side) Total:856 Winner Motion Carried |
發展公共交通應以鐵路為主 (Debate Replay) |
|
17th match (HSI：21108) |
2008.05.09(Fri) | 6:00pm~7:30pm |
PHC WING KWONG COLLEGE (Opposition Side) Winner Motion Carried |
南海區南海一中 (Affirmative Side) |
高等教育進修是脫離貧窮的主要方法 (Debate Replay) |
|
18th match |
2008.03.19(Wed) | 1:30pm~3:00pm |
CHRISTIAN & MISSIONARY ALLIANCE SUN KEI SECONDARY SCHOOL (Opposition Side) Total:799 Winner Motion Carried |
南海區華光中學 (Affirmative Side) Total:756 |
經濟發展優先於環境保護利多於弊 (Debate Replay) |
|
19th match (HSI：21108) |
2008.03.30(Sun) | 5:00pm~6:30pm |
CARMEL PAK U SECONDARY SCHOOL (Opposition Side) |
南海平洲高中 (Affirmative Side) Winner Motion Carried |
英雄是時勢所創造的 (Debate Replay) |
|
20th match (HSI：21108) |
2008.03.30(Sun) | 10:30am~12:00pm |
ST BONAVENTURE COLLEGE & HIGH SCHOOL (Opposition Side) |
南海區南海一中 (Affirmative Side) Winner Motion Carried |
中學生不應聆聽流行歌曲 (Debate Replay) |
|
21st match |
2008.03.30(Sun) | 1:00pm~2:30pm |
Hang Seng School of Commerce (Opposition Side) Winner Motion Carried |
南海區南海中學 (Affirmative Side) |
中學應用地方方言教授科目而非普通話 (Debate Replay) |
|
22nd match |
2008.03.30(Sun) | 3:00pm~4:30pm |
HOLY TRINITY COLLEGE (Opposition Side) Winner Motion Carried |
南海小塘中學 (Affirmative Side) |
溫飽是談道德的先決條件 (Debate Replay) |
|
23rd match (HSI：21108) |
2008.03.31(Mon) | 4:30pm~6:00pm |
SACRED HEART CANOSSIAN COLLEGE (Opposition Side) |
南海區鹽步中學 (Affirmative Side) Winner Motion Carried |
逆境有利人才成長 (Debate Replay) |
|
24th match (HSI：22617) |
2008.04.02(Wed) | 4:30pm~6:00pm |
CCC MING YIN COLLEGE (Affirmative Side) Total:816 Winner Motion Carried |
南海區南海實驗中學 (Opposition Side) Total:816 |
學校應強制中學生參與義工服務 (Debate Replay) |
|
25th match |
2008.04.19(Sat) | 4:30pm~6:00pm |
KOWLOON TRUE LIGHT MIDDLE SCHOOL (Opposition Side) Total:738 |
南海區南海一中 (Affirmative Side) Total:776 Winner Motion Carried |
高薪養廉能夠消除腐敗現象 (Debate Replay) |
|
26th match (HSI：23285) |
2008.04.05(Sat) | 10:30am~12:00pm |
SKH LAM KAU MOW SECONDARY SCHOOL (Affirmative Side) Total:791 Winner Motion Carried |
南海區桃園中學 (Opposition Side) Total:796 |
文科比理科對現今社會發展更為重要 (Debate Replay) |
|
27th match (HSI：23285) |
2008.04.05(Sat) | 1:30pm~3:00pm |
ST. MARK'S SCHOOL (Affirmative Side) Total:827 |
南海區平洲高中 (Opposition Side) Total:851 Winner Motion Carried |
網上言論受法律管制弊多於利 (Debate Replay) |
|
28th match |
2008.04.01(Tue) | 4:45pm~6:00pm |
KING'S COLLEGE (Affirmative Side) Total:841 |
南海區南海中學 (Opposition Side) Total:837 Winner Motion Carried |
廣告包裝比貨品質素更易令商品成功 (Debate Replay) |
|
29th match |
2008.04.06(Sun) | 10:30am~12:00pm |
SHUN LEE CATHOLIC SECONDARY SCHOOL (Affirmative Side) Total:780 |
南海區石門中學獅山校區 (Opposition Side) Total:883 Winner Motion Carried |
文才比口才更重要 (Debate Replay) |
|
30th match |
2008.04.06(Sun) | 1:30pm~2:30pm |
HK & KLN KAIFONG WOMEN'S ASSOCIATION SUN FONG CHUNG COLLEGE (Affirmative Side) Total:849 Winner Motion Carried |
南海區鹽步中學 (Opposition Side) Total:837 |
購買盜版者應負上法律責任 (Debate Replay) |
|
31st match |
2008.04.06(Sun) | 3:00pm~4:30pm |
TAK SUN SECONDARY SCHOOL (Affirmative Side) Total:808 |
南海區南海實驗中學 (Opposition Side) Total:825 Winner Motion Carried |
過程比結果更為重要 (Debate Replay) |
|
32nd match |
2008.03.15(Sat) | 2:30pm~3:30pm |
CHING CHUNG HAU PO WOON SECONDARY SCHOOL (Affirmative Side) Total:833 |
南海區南海中學 (Opposition Side) Total:868 Winner Motion Carried |
安樂死應予以合法化 (Debate Replay) |
D. Inter-city Secondary schools Cantonese section (Semi-finals) (2 teams from Hong Kong and 2 teams from overseas in the semi-finals)
|
Match |
Date |
Time |
Team A |
Team B |
Motion (Double click the motion for review) |
|
33rd match (HSI：25169) |
2008.05.27(Tue) | 4:30am~6:00pm | ELCHK LUTHERAN SECONDARY SCHOOL (Affirmative Side) Winner Motion Carried |
南海區南海實驗中學 (Opposition Side) |
中學生炒股利大於弊 (Debate Replay) |
|
34th match (HSI：25063) |
2008.05.17(Sat) | 1:00~2:30pm | THE MISSION COVENANT CHURCH HOLM GLAD COLLEGE (Affirmative Side) |
南海區平洲高中 (Opposition Side) Winner Motion Carried |
強國應先富民 (Debate Replay) |
D. Inter-city Primary schools Cantonese section (Final) (1 team from Hong Kong and 1 team from China in the Final)
|
Match |
Date |
Time |
Team A |
Team B |
Motion (Double click the motion for review) |
| 35th match | 2008.06.02(Mon) | 6:00pm~7:30pm | ELCHK LUTHERAN SECONDARY SCHOOL (Opposition Side) |
南海區平洲高中 (Affirmative Side) Winner Motion Carried |
新聞自由更有利社會穩定 (Debate Replay) |
F. Inter-city Secondary schools Beijing-HK Putonghua section (1st round)
|
Match |
Date |
Time |
Team A |
Team B |
Motion (Double click the motion for review) |
|
1st match (HSI：22849) |
2008.04.07(Mon) | 4:30pm~6:00pm | KING LING COLLEGE (Affirmative Side) Total:972 |
北京市第四中學 (Opposition Side) Total:1130 Winner Motion Carried |
高薪養廉能夠有效防止腐敗 (Debate Replay) |
|
2nd match (HSI：23137) |
2008.04.08(Tue) | 4:30pm~6:00pm | PHC WING KWONG COLLEGE (Affirmative Side) Total:954 Winner Motion Carried |
Beijing National Day School 北京巿十一學校 (Opposition Side) Total:951 |
人類是環境的保護者 (Debate Replay) |
|
3rd match (HSI：23872) |
2008.04.09(Wed) | 4:30pm~6:00pm | KIANGSU - CHEKIANG COLLEGE (KWAI CHUNG) (Opposition Side) Total:1058 |
北京市丰台區丰台第二中學 (Affirmative Side) Total:1106 Winner Motion Carried |
拾金不昧應該給予物質獎勵 (Debate Replay) |
|
4th match |
2008.05.19(Mon) | 4:30pm~6:00pm | SKH LAM KAU MOW SECONDARY SCHOOL (Affirmative Side) Total:951 Winner Motion Carried |
北京市順義區第一中學 (Opposition Side) Total:876 |
手提電話附有拍照功能利多於弊 (Debate Replay) |
|
5th match (HSI：24264) |
2008.04.11(Fri) | 4:30pm~6:00pm | HK & KLN KAIFONG WOMEN'S ASSOCIATION SUN FONG CHUNG COLLEGE (Opposition Side) Total:954 Winner Motion Carried |
北京市蘋果園中學 (Affirmative Side) Total:954 |
中國內地懲治貪腐問題應該動用死刑 (Debate Replay) |
|
6th match (HSI：24264) |
2008.04.12(Sat) | 10:30am~12:00pm | ST BONAVENTURE COLLEGE & HIGH SCHOOL (Opposition Side) Total:946 |
北京市首師附屬育新學校 (Affirmative Side) Total:949 Winner Motion Carried |
以暴制暴是打擊恐怖主義最有效的途徑 (Debate Replay) |
|
7th match |
2008.04.12(Sat) | 1:30pm~3:00pm | THE MISSION COVENANT CHURCH HOLM GLAD COLLEGE (Opposition Side) Total:853 Winner Motion Carried |
北京市密雲縣第二中學 (Affirmative Side) Total:849 |
科技的發展會促進人類的全面發展 (Debate Replay) |
|
8th match |
2008.04.12(Sat) | 4:30pm~6:00pm | KOWLOON TRUE LIGHT MIDDLE SCHOOL (Opposition Side) Total:1048 Winner Motion Carried |
北京市密雲縣第三中學 (Affirmative Side) Total:973 |
金錢是萬惡之源 (Debate Replay) |
F. Inter-city Beijing-HK Secondary schools Putonghua section (1 team from Hong Kong and 1 team from Beijing in the Final)
|
Match |
Date |
Time |
Team A |
Team B |
Motion (Double click the motion for review) |
|
9th match (HSI：25742) |
2008.05.19(Mon) | 4:30pm~6:00pm | KOWLOON TRUE LIGHT MIDDLE SCHOOL (Opposition Side) Total:958 |
北京市第四中學 (Affirmative Side) Total:960 Winner Motion Carried |
非洲國家艾滋病問題的惡化是因為缺乏教育 (Debate Replay) |
|
Match |
Date |
Time |
Team A |
Team B |
Motion (Double click the motion for review) |
|
1st match (HSI：24264) |
2008.04.13(Sun) | 10:30am~12:00pm |
German Swiss International School (Opposition Side) Total:974 Winner Motion Carried |
The Second High School Attached to Beijing Normal University (Affirmative Side) Total:953 |
That the computer has replaced the teacher in today's classroom. (Debate Replay) |
|
2nd match (HSI：24264) |
2008.04.13(Sun) | 1:30pm~3:00pm |
PUI CHING MIDDLE SCHOOL (Opposition Side) Total:907 Winner Motion Carried |
Beijing No.14 Middle School (Affirmative Side) Total:718 |
That the computer has replaced the teacher in today's classroom. (Debate Replay) |
|
3rd match (HSI：24264) |
2008.04.13(Sun) | 3:30pm~5:00pm |
South Island School (Opposition Side) Total:969 *Reference:Rule 4.7.4 |
The No.80 High School of Beijing (Affirmative Side) Total:968 Winner Motion Carried |
That the computer has replaced the teacher in today's classroom. (Debate Replay) |
|
4th match |
2008.04.14(Mon) | 4:30pm~6:00pm |
SHUN LEE CATHOLIC SECONDARY SCHOOL (Opposition Side) Total:803 |
Beijing 101 Middle School (Affirmative Side) Total:841 Winner Motion Carried |
That it is morally acceptable to experiment on animals for the development of drugs for humans. (Debate Replay) |
|
5th match (HSI：24311) |
2008.04.24(Tue) | 4:30pm~6:00pm |
SACRED HEART CANOSSIAN COLLEGE (Affirmative Side) Total:914 Winner Motion Carried |
Beijing Hai Dian Experimental Middlle School (Opposition Side) Total:869 |
That there should be a worldwide ban on the use of driftnets to catch fish. (Debate Replay) |
|
6th match (HSI：23984) |
2008.04.16(Wed) | 4:30pm~6:00pm |
Hang Seng School of Commerce (Opposition Side) Total:826 Winner Motion Carried |
Beijing No.12 High School (Affirmative Side) Total:841 *Reference:Rule 4.7.4 |
That a ban on advertising is a restriction of the freedom of speech. (Debate Replay) |
E. Inter-city Beijing-HK Secondary schools English section (Final) (1 team from Hong Kong and 1 team from Beijing in the Final)
|
Match |
Date |
Time |
Team A |
Team B |
Motion (Double click the motion for review) |
|
7th match (HSI：25552) |
2008.05.20(Tue) | 4:30pm~6:00pm | SACRED HEART CANOSSIAN COLLEGE (Opposition Side) Total:932 *Reference:Rule 4.7.4 |
Beijing 101 Middle School (Affirmative Side) Total:924 Winner Motion Carried |
That the olympic games have become too politicised. (Debate Replay) |
H. Inter-city Shanghai-HK Secondary school Putonghua section (1st round)
|
Match |
Date |
Time |
Team A |
Team B |
Motion (Double click the motion for review) |
|
1st match (HSI：24187) |
2008.04.17(Thu) | 4:30pm~6:00pm | HK & KLN KAIFONG WOMEN'S ASSOCIATION SUN FONG CHUNG COLLEGE (Affirmative Side) Total:872 |
上海市北海中學 (Opposition Side) Total:880 Winner Motion Carried |
科技使世界變大 (Debate Replay) |
|
2nd match (HSI：24667) |
2008.04.26(Fri) | 4:30pm~6:00pm | KIANGSU - CHEKIANG COLLEGE (KWAI CHUNG) (Affirmative Side) Total:914 Winner Motion Carried |
上海市江宁學校 (Opposition Side) Total:903 |
經濟發展優先於環境保護利多於弊 (Debate Replay) |
|
3rd match (HSI：24667) |
2008.05.04(Sun) | 6:00pm~7:30pm | PHC WING KWONG COLLEGE (Affirmative Side) Total:964 |
上海民辦中遠實驗學校 (Opposition Side) Total:1030 Winner Motion Carried |
天災比人禍更為可怕 (Debate Replay) |
|
4th match |
2008.04.19(Sat) | 1:00pm~2:30pm | KING LING COLLEGE (Affirmative Side) Total:939 Winner Motion Carried |
上海市兴陇中學 (Opposition Side) Total:835 |
新聞自由對社會穩定利大於弊 (Debate Replay) |
|
5th match (HSI：24667) |
2008.04.19(Sat) | 2:30pm~4:00pm | SHATIN PUI YING COLLEGE (Affirmative Side) Total:911 |
上海市進華中學 (Opposition Side) Total:1010 Winner Motion Carried |
中學生出國留學利大於弊 (Debate Replay) |
|
6th match (HSI：24197) |
2008.04.25(Fri) | 6:00pm~7:30pm | CARMEL BUNNAN TONG MEMORIAL SECONDARY SCHOOL (Affirmative Side) Total:940 |
上海市七寶中學 (Opposition Side) Total:946 Winner Motion Carried |
考試制度是衡量個人才智的最佳途徑 (Debate Replay) |
|
7th match |
2008.05.21 (Wed) |
3:30pm ~ 4:30pm | 伊利沙伯中學舊生會湯國華中學 (Affirmative Side) Winner Motion Carried |
上海市田園高級中學 (Opposition Side) |
互聯網是使現今人際關係疏離的主要原因 (Debate Replay) |
|
8th match |
2008.04.20(Sun) |
3:30pm~6:00pm | YAN CHAI HOSPITAL LAN CHI PAT MEMORIAL SECONDARY SCHOOL (Affirmative Side) Total:949 Winner Motion Carried |
上海市北虹高級中學 (Opposition Side) Total:937 |
高等教育應該嚴進寬出 (Debate Replay) |
|
9th match (HSI：23811) |
2008.04.21(Mon) | 4:30pm~6:00pm | ST JOSEPH'S ANGL ENGLISH SCHOOL (Affirmative Side) Winner Motion Carried |
上海市虹口高級中學 (Opposition Side) |
學高為師 (Debate Replay) |
|
10th match (HSI：23901) |
2008.04.22(Tue) | 4:30pm~6:00pm | ST BONAVENTURE COLLEGE & HIGH SCHOOL (Affirmative Side) Total:937 Winner Motion Carried |
上海市北郊高級中學 (Opposition Side) Total:905 |
政府應該限制名人賣醫藥廣告 (Debate Replay) |
|
11th match |
2008.05.04(Sun) | 3:30pm~5:00pm | SACRED HEART CANOSSIAN COLLEGE (Opposition Side) Total:942 |
上海市澄衷高級中學 (Affirmative Side) Total:951 Winner Motion Carried |
全球經濟一體化是第三世界的落後主要原因 (Debate Replay) |
|
12th match (HSI：24258) |
2008.04.24(Thu) | 6:00pm~7:30pm | SHUN LEE CATHOLIC SECONDARY SCHOOL (Opposition Side) Total:938 Winner Motion Carried |
上海市繼光高級中學 (Affirmative Side) Total:891 |
消費文化提升人類生活素質 (Debate Replay) |
|
13th match (HSI：24197) |
2008.04.25(Fri) | 4:30pm~6:00pm | THE MISSION COVENANT CHURCH HOLM GLAD COLLEGE (Affirmative Side) Total:994 Winner Motion Carried |
上海市文來中學 (Opposition Side) Total:843 |
教育的目的是為了追求個人的成功 (Debate Replay) |
| 14th match (HSI：24939) |
2008.04.28(Mon) | 6:00pm~7:30pm | ST JOSEPH'S COLLEGE (Affirmative Side) Total:867 Winner Motion Carried |
上海市閔行第二中學 (Opposition Side) Total:808 |
藝術商品化利大於弊 (Debate Replay) |
H. Inter-city Shanghai-HK Secondary schools Putonghua section (Final) (1 team from Hong Kong and 1 team from Shanghai in the Final)
|
Match |
Date |
Time |
Team A |
Team B |
Motion (Double click the motion for review) |
|
15th match (HSI：25618) |
2008.05.25 (Sun) |
|
基督教聖約教會堅樂中學 (Opposition Side) Winner Motion Carried |
上海民辦中遠實驗學校 (Affirmative Side) |
衣食足然後知榮辱 (Debate Replay) |
G. Inter-city Shanghai-HK Secondary schools English section (1st round)
|
Match |
Date |
Time |
Team A |
Team B |
Motion (Double click the motion for review) |
|
1st match (HSI：24197) |
2008.04.26(Sat) | 10:30am~12:00pm |
YMCA OF HONG KONG CHRISTIAN COLLEGE (Affirmative Side) Total:844 (1 vote) *Reference:Rule 4.7.4 |
Shanghai Luochuan School (Opposition Side) Total:812 (2 votes) Winner Motion Carried |
That there should be an internationally agreed minimum wage. (Debate Replay) |
|
2nd match (HSI：24197) |
2008.04.26(Sat) | 1:30pm~3:00pm |
ELCHK LUTHERAN SECONDARY SCHOOL (Affirmative Side) Total:745 |
Peijia Bilingual School Shanghai (Opposition Side) Total:752 Winner Motion Carried |
That there should be an internationally agreed minimum wage. (Debate Replay) |
|
3rd match (HSI：24197) |
2008.04.27(Sun) | 10:30am~12:00pm |
HEEP YUNN SCHOOL (Affirmative Side) Total:889 |
Shanghai QiBao Middle School (Opposition Side) Total:915 Winner Motion Carried |
That tobacco should be regulated as an addictive drug. (Debate Replay) |
|
4th match |
2008.04.27(Sun) |
1:30pm~3:00pm |
South Island School (Affirmative Side) Total:1038 Winner Motion Carried |
Shanghai Wenlai Senior High School (Opposition Side) Total:891 |
That tobacco should be regulated as an addictive drug. (Debate Replay) |
|
5th match (HSI：24197) |
2008.04.27(Sun) |
3:00pm~4:30pm |
SHUN LEE CATHOLIC SECONDARY SCHOOL (Affirmative Side) Total:891 Winner Motion Carried |
Fuxing Senior High School Shanghai Total:859 (Opposition Side) |
That tobacco should be regulated as an addictive drug. (Debate Replay) |
|
6th match (HSI：24197) |
2008.04.27(Sun) |
4:30pm~6:00pm |
German Swiss International School (Affirmative Side) Total:959 Winner Motion Carried |
Shanghai Tin Yuen Secondary (Opposition Side) Total:780 |
That tobacco should be regulated as an addictive drug. (Debate Replay) |
G. Inter-city Shanghai-HK Secondary schools English section (Final) (1 team from Hong Kong and 1 team from Shanghai in the Final)
|
Match |
Date |
Time |
Team A |
Team B |
Motion (Double click the motion for review) |
|
7th match (HSI：25533) |
2008.05.21 (Wed) | 4:30pm~6:00pm | South Island School (Affirmative Side) Total:974 Winner Motion Carried |
Shanghai QiBao Middle School (Opposition Side) Total:913 |
That a government should have the right to block internet portals. (Debate Replay) |
I. Inter-city Secondary schools English section (1st round)
|
Match |
Date |
Time |
Team A |
Team B |
Motion (Double click the motion for review) |
|
1st match (HSI：24721) |
2008.04.28(Mon) | 4:30pm~6:00pm |
PUI CHING MIDDLE SCHOOL (Affirmative Side) Total:878 |
馬來西亞 沙巴崇正中學 (Opposition Side) Total:952 Winner Motion Carried |
That it is better to have time than money. (Debate Replay) |
|
2nd match (HSI：24939) |
2008.04.29(Tue) | 4:30pm~6:00pm |
PO LEUNG KUK CELINE HO YAM TONG COLLEGE (Affirmative Side) Total:811 |
台北市立木柵國民中學 (Opposition Side) Total:854 Winner Motion Carried |
That sex education should be a compulsory component of every child's secondary years. (Debate Replay) |
|
4th match |
2008.05.13(Tue) | 6:00pm~7:30pm |
ST. MARK'S SCHOOL (Opposition Side) Total:865 |
佛山巿南海區 石門中學 (Affirmative Side) Total:881 Winner Motion Carried |
That housewives should be paid a monthly wage. (Debate Replay) |
|
5th match (HSI：26241) |
2008.05.10(Sat) | 1:30pm~3:00pm |
Hang Seng School of Commerce (Affirmative Side) Winner Motion Carried |
佛山巿南海區 石門中學 (Opposition Side) |
That the United Nations has outlived its usefulness. (Debate Replay) |
|
7th match |
2008.05.11(Sun) | 10:30am~12:00pm |
YMCA OF HONG KONG CHRISTIAN COLLEGE (Affirmative Side) Winner Motion Carried |
佛山巿南海區 南海中學 (Opposition Side) |
That martial arts should play no role in the olympic games. (Debate Replay) |
|
8th match (HSI：26241) |
2008.05.10(Sun) | 6:00pm~7:30pm |
PLK NGAN PO LING COLLEGE (Affirmative Side) Winner Motion Carried |
佛山巿南海區 鹽步中學 (Opposition Side) |
That the United Nations has outlived its usefulness. (Debate Replay) |
|
9th match (HSI：26241) |
2008.05.11(Sun) | 1:00pm~2:30pm |
South Island School (Affirmative Side) Winner Motion Carried |
佛山巿南海區 南海中學 (Opposition Side) |
That martial arts should play no role in the olympic games. (Debate Replay) |
I. Inter-city Secondary schools English section (Final) (1 team from Hong Kong and 1 team from overseas in the Final)
|
Match |
Date |
Time |
Team A |
Team B |
Motion (Double click the motion for review) |
|
10th match (HSI：25063) |
2008.05.18(Sun) | 10:30am~12:00pm | South Island School (Affirmative Side) Total:947 Winner Motion Carried |
Sabah Tshung Tsin Secondary School (Opposition Side) Total:919 |
That the US should withdraw its troops from Iraq. (Debate Replay) |
J. Inter-city Secondary schools Putonghua section (1st round)
|
Match |
Date |
Time |
Team A |
Team B |
Motion (Double click the motion for review) |
|
1st match (HSI:25618) |
2008.05.23(Sun) | 3:00pm~4:30pm |
ST JOSEPH'S ANGLO-CHINESE SCHOOL (Opposition Side) |
Sabah Tshung Tsin Secondary School (Affirmative Side) Winner Motion Carried |
同性戀是個人問題而非社會問題 (Debate Replay) |
|
2nd match (HSI：25516) |
2008.05.04(Sun) | 1:30pm~3:00pm |
KIANGSU - CHEKIANG COLLEGE (KWAI CHUNG) (Opposition Side) Total:938 Winner Motion Carried |
佛山巿南海區 鹽步中學 (Affirmative Side) Total:909 |
自由貿易是公平的 (Debate Replay) |
|
3rd match (HSI：25666) |
2008.05.021(Mon) | 6:00pm~7:00pm |
PHC WING KWONG COLLEGE (Opposition Side) Winner Motion Carried |
台北市立木柵國民中學 (Affirmative Side) |
城巿規劃是環保成效的最主要決定因素 (Debate Replay) |
|
4th match |
2008.05.17(Sat) | 4:30pm~6:00pm | HK & KLN KAIFONG WOMEN'S ASSOCIATION SUN FONG CHUNG COLLEGE |
佛山巿南海區 黃岐中學 Winner Motion Carried |
中國應再多開設一個地方股票市場 (Debate Replay) |
J. Inter-city Secondary schools Putonghua section (Final)
(1 team from Hong Kong and 1 team from overseas in the Final)
|
Match |
Date |
Time |
Team A |
Team B |
Motion (Double click the motion for review) |
|
5th match (HSI：24119) |
2008.06.02(Mon) | 5:00pm~6:00pm | PHC WING KWONG COLLEGE (Affirmative Side) Winner Motion Carried |
佛山巿南海區 黃岐中學 (Opposition Side) |
學歷比資歷更為重要 (Debate Replay) |
K. Inter-city Primary schools English section (1st round)
|
Match |
Date |
Time |
Team A |
Team B |
Motion (Double click the motion for review) |
|
1st match (HSI：25755) |
2008.05.07(Wed) | 4:30pm~5:30pm |
Yaumati Catholic Primary School (Affirmative Side) Total:873 Winner Motion Carried |
江蘇張家港市東萊小學 (Opposition Side) Total:663 |
That the computer is a student's best friend. (Debate Replay) |
|
2nd match (HSI：25755) |
2008.05.08(Thu) | 4:30pm~5:30pm |
W F Joseph Lee Primary School (Affirmative Side) Total:853 Winner Motion Carried |
北京市朝陽區白家莊小學(朝陽區小學) (Opposition Side) Total:801 |
Television advertising has more benefits than harms. (Debate Replay) |
|
3rd match (HSI：26241) |
2008.05.09(Fri) | 4:30pm~5:30pm | S.K.H. Good Shepherds Primary School (Affirmative Side) Total:743 |
北京市西城師范附小 (Opposition Side) Total:893 Winner Motion Carried |
That the internet has made the world a smaller place. (Debate Replay) |
K. Inter-city Primary schools English section (Final) (1 team from Hong Kong and 1 team from overseas in the Final)
|
Match |
Date |
Time |
Team A |
Team B |
Motion (Double click the motion for review) |
|
4th match (HSI：25063) |
2008.05.18(Sun) | 2pm~3pm | Yaumati Catholic Primary School (Affirmative Side) Total:849 |
北京市西城師范附小 (Opposition Side) Total:856 Winner Motion Carried |
The mobile phone is a child's best friend. (Debate Replay) |
L. Inter-city Primary school Putonghua section (1st round)
|
Match |
Date |
Time |
Team A |
Team B |
Motion (Double click the motion for review) |
|
1st match (HSI：26241) |
2008.05.10(Sat) | 10:30am~11:30am |
Kowloon Bay St. John The Baptist Catholic Primary School (Affirmative Side) |
寧波市太古小學 (Opposition Side) Winner Motion Carried |
修習外語比修習母語更為重要 (Debate Replay) |
| 2nd match | 2008.05.17(Sat) | 3:00pm~4:30pm |
Christian Alliance S.Y. Yeh Memorial Primary School Winner Motion Carried |
寧波市通途小學 | 學校應禁止學生穿帶名牌物品回校 (Debate Replay) |
|
3rd match (HSI：26241) |
2008.05.10(Sat) | 3:00pm~4:00pm |
Ping Shek Estate Catholic Primary School (Affirmative Side) |
寧波市栎木小學 (Opposition Side) Winner Motion Carried |
參加補習班是有效令學生成績提升的主要途徑 (Debate Replay) |
|
4th match |
2008.05.11(Sun) | 3:00pm~4:00pm |
Tak Sun School (Affirmative Side) |
寧波市中山東路小學 (Opposition Side) Winner Motion Carried |
電腦必將取代書本 (Debate Replay) |
| 5th match |
2008.05.16(Sun) |
6:00pm~7:30pm |
Kowloon City Baptist Church Hay Nien Primary School (Affirmative Side) Winner Motion Carried |
寧波市東郊中心小學 (Opposition Side) |
網上購物對市民利多於弊 (Debate Replay) |
|
6th match (HSI：26241) |
2008.05.11(Sun) |
5:00pm~6:00pm |
Lok Sin Tong Primary School (Affirmative Side) Winner Motion Carried |
江蘇張家港市東萊小學 (Opposition Side) |
小學應全面取消考試 (Debate Replay) |
|
7th match |
2008.05.13(Tue) | 4:30pm~5:30pm |
Stewards Pooi Kei Primary School (Opposition Side) Winner Motion Carried |
佛山市鐵軍小學 (Affirmative Side) |
文物應被送回發源國 (Debate Replay) |
|
8th match |
2008.05.28(Wed) | 4:30pm~5:30pm |
Buddhist Wing Yan School (A.M.) (Opposition Side) Winner Motion Carried |
佛山市南海區獅山鎮官窯中心小學 (Affirmative Side) |
學習是快樂的 (Debate Replay) |
|
9th match (HSI：25513) |
2008.05.22(Thu) | 4:30pm~5:30pm |
S.K.H Good SHEPHERD PRIMARY SCHOOL (P.M. SESSION) (Affirmative Side) |
北京市東城區和平里第一小學 (Opposition Side) Winner Motion Carried |
學校不應要求小學生背誦中國經典文學詩詞 (Debate Replay) |
|
10th match (HSI：25618) |
2008.05.23(Fri) | 4:30pm~5:30pm | Po Leung Kuk Grandmont Primary School (Opposition Side) Winner Motion Carried |
北京市東城區青年湖小學 (Affirmative Side) |
家長讓小學生參加大量的課外活動是拔苗助長 (Debate Replay) |
|
11th match |
2008.05.24(Sat) | 10:30am~11:30am |
Alliance Primary School, Whampoa (Opposition Side) |
北京市東城區燈市口小學 (Affirmative Side) Winner Motion Carried |
中國應該在小學語文課本加入中國經典篇章 (Debate Replay) |
|
12th match (HSI：25610) |
2008.05.14(Wed) | 4:30pm~6:00pm | 南海實驗小學 (Opposition Side) Winner Motion Carried |
北京市西城區宏廟小學 (Affirmative Side) |
小學生考試應取消選擇題 (Debate Replay) |
|
13th match (HSI：25618) |
2008.05.24(Sat) | 3:00pm~4:00pm | 南海區官窯中心小學 (Opposition Side) |
北京市朝陽區白家庄小學 (Affirmative Side) Winner Motion Carried |
小學成立學生會有助學校建設 (Debate Replay) |
|
14th match |
2008.05.25(Sun) | 10:30am~11:30am | 南海區海三路小學 (Opposition Side) |
北京市朝陽區芳草地小學 (Affirmative Side) Winner Motion Carried |
小學教育中，人格培養重于知識積累 (Debate Replay) |
|
15th match |
2008.05.25(Sun) | 1:30pm~2:30pm | 佛山市桂園小學 (Opposition Side) Winner Motion Carried |
北京市西城區奮鬥小學 (Affirmative Side) |
寓學于樂比寓樂于學重要 (Debate Replay) |
|
16th match (HSI：25618) |
2008.05.25(Sun) | 4:30pm~6:00pm | 佛山市南海區南海師範附屬小學 (Opposition Side) |
北京市朝陽區安貞第二小學 (Affirmative Side) Winner Motion Carried |
辯論賽中，辯論技巧比論內容更重要 (Debate Replay) |
L. Inter-city Primary schools Putonghua section (Final) (1 team from Hong Kong and 1 team from overseas in the Final)
|
Match |
Date |
Time |
Team A |
Team B |
Motion (Double click the motion for review) |
| 17th match | 2008.06.03(Tue) | 4:30pm~6:00pm | 佛山市南海實驗小學 (Opposition Side) Winner Motion Carried |
北京市朝陽區芳草地小學 (Affirmative Side) |
全球變暖發展中國家應該負更大責任 (Debate Replay) |
M. Inter-city Nanhai-Hongkong Putonghua Invitation Match (1 team from Hong Kong and 1 team from overseas in the Final)
|
Match |
Date |
Time |
Team A |
Team B |
Motion (Double click the motion for review) |
|
1st match (HSI：22456) |
2008.07.01(Tue) | 11:30pm~12:30pm | 聖若瑟英文中學 (Opposition Side) Winner Motion Carried |
南海中學 (Affirmative Side) |
科技是解決當前能源危機的根本 |
Last Updated: 2008-06-03 6:00pm
